Clearing the Air About the Psychological Effects
Martha Shuping, M.D.
do women have abortions?
At least 70 percent of women having abortions say they believe it is
immoral.(1) But they choose against their
conscience because of pressure from others and their circumstances.
Most women choose abortion out of fear--fear of not being able to raise
a child, fear of losing their partner if they do not have an abortion,
fear of losing control over their lives, etc. Some polls show that more
than 80 percent say they would have completed their pregnancies under better
circumstances or with more support from the people they love.(2)
It is precisely because so many women who abort are acting against their
consciences and maternal instincts that the psychological impact of abortion
can be so profound.
Didn't former U.S. Surgeon General
C. Everett Koop conclude that there are no psychological consequences from
What Dr. Koop reported to President Reagan was that all the studies
on abortion complications were seriously flawed. As a result, the data
was simply inadequate to determine the extent and degree
of the psychological impact of abortion. He made a recommendation for a
government-funded study to answer this question. Unfortunately, this study
was never done.
Some extremists have twisted Dr. Koop's letter to the President to mean,
"Koop didn't find anything, so nothing exists." Dr. Koop has publicly refuted
this misrepresentation of his views. He has stated that he is personally
convinced, even by the existing evidence, that many women do suffer
serious post-abortion psychological problems.(3)
It is the degree of this problem that has not been measured.
Still, don't most experts agree
that there is no significant psychological impact from abortion?
While many abortion proponents will discount the psychological costs
of abortion, others are more candid. For example, Dr. Julius Fogel has
personally performed more than 20,000 abortions. He is unique in that he
is both a psychiatrist and obstetrician, and he insists that "every
woman, whatever her background or sexuality, has a trauma at destroying
a pregnancy....[I]t is not as harmless and casual an event as many in the
pro-abortion crowd insist."(4)
In fact, there are more than 375 studies dealing with the psychological
impact of abortion on women. All show that at least a minority of women,
typically between 10 and 20 percent, have one or more negative reactions
shortly after an abortion. Studies looking at long-term reactions indicate
that the longer after an abortion one looks, the more negative reactions
will be reported.
So what are the psychological
aftereffects of abortion?
Every woman is different. They each have different responses in different
time frames. Some women repress or are unaware of any aftereffects for
Commonly reported reactions include: feelings of guilt, shame, anxiety,
helplessness, grief and/or remorse; uncontrollable crying; feelings of
anger, bitterness, and resentment; feelings of distrust and betrayal; lowered
self-esteem; avoidance of babies, small children, or anything to do with
pregnancy; fear of future pregnancies or, alternatively, a desire to have
a "replacement" baby; flashbacks to the abortion experience; nightmares
or sleeping disorders; depression; sexual dysfunction; eating disorders;
substance abuse; self-destructive behavior; broken or abusive relationships;
problems bonding with other children; suicidal thoughts or tendencies;
and other problems.
A trained post-abortion counselor can be of tremendous help in resolving
You said that some of these reactions
might be delayed or repressed. Are there times or circumstances when negative
reactions are more likely to occur?
Delayed reactions are often triggered by subsequent life events such
as the birth of a child, the death of a loved one, the end of a relationship,
a religious conversion, or even physical changes like menopause.
Many women have "anniversary reactions," such as anxiety attacks, depression,
suicidal impulses, or abdominal cramping, around the anniversary date or
month of the abortion or around the time when their babies would have been
Dr. Martha Shuping, M.D., is a psychiatrist with more than
ten years of experience in helping women with post-abortion issues.
1. Los Angeles Times Poll, March 19, 1989.
See also Zimmerman, M., Passage Through Abortion (New York: Praeger
Publishers, 1977) and Reardon, D., Aborted Women: Silent No More
(Chicago: Loyola University Press, 1987).
2. Reardon, D., Making Abortion Rare (Springfield,
IL: Acorn Books, 1996).
3. "Revisiting the Koop Report," The Post Abortion
Review, Summer 1995, 1-3. See also "Surgeon General C. Everett Koop's
Statement on Post-Abortion Syndrome," Life Cycle, September 1989,
4. McCarthy, C., "A Psychological View of Abortion,"
St. Paul Sunday Pioneer Press, The Washington Post, March 7, 1971.
Dr. Fogel reiterated the same view in a second interview with McCarthy
in 1989, "The Real Anguish of Abortions," The Washington Post, Feb.